I logged what actually happened in my own time, and the results surprised me. Boiled down, how granular the filters are explains why old recommendations age badly.

I sat with this question for a while in my own time, and the numbers told a clearer story than I did. More than anything, how wide the distance filter goes drives the outcome more than luck does. The gap was widest to a degree that mattered regardless of which city I set.

I logged what actually happened on this, and ended up somewhere unexpected. In practice whether messaging is capped is where the real differences show up. It was consistent consistently enough to trust across every option I tried. Your mileage may differ honestly, rather than taking my word for it.

If I were starting again, I would look at:

  • Whether the app requires a social login — this is the one I would check first.
  • Whether the sign-up asks for a phone number
  • Check how it performs on a slow connection
  • Check whether the filters narrow by anything that matters — the marketing never covers this.

I approached this the boring way while comparing them, so I am fairly confident in the shape of it. Once you look closely, whether messaging is capped turns out to matter far more than the interface. It became obvious without exception despite what the marketing implied. Worth testing yourself on balance, the detail varies a lot by city.