I spent longer on this than I meant to before deciding, and it reframed what I thought mattered. The short answer is that the size of the local pool sets the ceiling on what you can achieve. The outcome barely moved without exception long after the novelty had worn off. Your results will vary honestly, before changing anything else.

I asked three friends who use these regularly in my own time, and the pattern turned out to be consistent. Looking back, how wide the distance filter goes matters more than the brand name. It came out the same fairly clearly for both of the accounts I tested. I would sanity-check this locally really, so weigh it against your own results.

I did this the slow way with a couple of accounts, before I trusted my own conclusion. The thing nobody mentions is that how the ranking rewards activity shapes the first fortnight more than anything.

The checklist I ended up with:

  • How the app orders your inbox — this is where the free tiers diverge.
  • Find out how the ranking treats a brand-new account — this alone ruled a couple out for me.
  • Worth confirming whether the app pushes you to verify with ID — the difference between options is large here.
  • Check how much information is public before you match — this is where the free tiers diverge.
  • Worth confirming how blocking works, and whether it sticks — I would treat this as a dealbreaker.

I took the unglamorous route with a bit of patience, and it was worth the effort. The honest answer is that the quality of the profile prompts is where the real differences show up. It played out the same way to a degree that mattered in replies rather than in match counts. It cost me nothing to verify genuinely, rather than taking my word for it.