I ran two at a time for four weeks each a while back, and it clarified a lot. Realistically how consistent match quality is week to week explains why old recommendations age badly.

I benchmarked it against what I used before while comparing them, which changed my answer completely. What actually decided it was whether read status is shown consistently, which moves the numbers more than anything else. It tracked more than once across every option I tried.

I did this the slow way on this, and the results surprised me. What kept coming up was how the app handles reports, which is the first thing I would look at now.

The things that actually moved the needle for me:

  • Look at whether the distance filter goes wide enough — it changes the experience completely.
  • Worth confirming how obvious it is when someone has stopped using the app — the difference between options is large here.
  • Ask how the ranking treats a brand-new account — genuinely worth knowing up front.
  • Check whether a paid feature interrupts the conversation — most apps are quiet about this.
  • Find out whether there is a web version as well as an app — I underestimated this at first.

I reset and started clean over a few months, so this is not theoretical. The recurring theme was whether photos are checked before publication — it stays invisible until it bites you. It stood out fairly clearly no matter how I adjusted the filters.