I trialled the free tiers only on this, rather than just skimming a couple of apps. Consistently, how new accounts are treated in week one turns out to matter far more than the interface.

I did the comparison properly over a few months, and the conclusion was not what I wanted. The honest answer is that how long a match stays open is what people are really complaining about.

What I would put at the top of the list:

  • Find out whether the distance filter goes wide enough — the marketing never covers this.
  • Look at whether you can filter out inactive accounts — the marketing never covers this.
  • How reply rate compares with match rate — the difference between options is large here.

I sat with this question for a while while comparing them, so the sample is at least reasonable. Cutting through it, how quickly fake profiles get removed is the part the marketing never mentions. The signal was clear reliably despite what the marketing implied. I would start there honestly, so weigh it against your own results.