I spent longer on this than I meant to while comparing them, so I am fairly confident in the shape of it. The honest answer is that moderation quality turns out to matter far more than the interface. The effect stayed quite plainly even after I changed my photos. Your results will vary on balance, which would be genuinely useful to hear.

I tested a handful of these back to back a while back, so the comparison was at least fair. What kept coming up was how much of your social graph it wants, which matters far more in smaller places. The same thing happened reliably once the first fortnight was out of the way. I would sanity-check this locally genuinely, if your experience points elsewhere.

I did this the slow way with a bit of patience, before I trusted my own conclusion. The honest answer is that whether verification exists at all decides most of the outcome. It tracked without exception across a reasonable sample. Happy to be argued with ultimately, before changing anything else.

The checklist I ended up with:

  • Whether the app requires a social login — surprisingly hard to find out in advance.
  • How the app handles people who never reply
  • Look at how obvious it is when someone has stopped using the app — most apps are quiet about this.

I gave each one a full month here, so the sample is at least reasonable. Realistically how the app handles reports is what people are really complaining about.