I went through this same question last year on this, and it was more revealing than I expected. What actually decided it was how the app handles reports, which separates the usable options from the rest. It played out the same way without exception in replies rather than in match counts. Check it against your own case ultimately, which would be genuinely useful to hear.

I made a spreadsheet, embarrassingly on this, which is where the interesting part started. More than anything, whether messaging is capped is the difference between two opposite reviews. The signal was clear without exception even after I changed my photos.

I stuck with it longer than most people would on this, and ended up somewhere unexpected. In my testing, how the app treats people who travel predicts your reply rate better than anything else. It held steady fairly clearly more clearly than anything else I looked at. That is the short version really, before committing any real time.

Concretely, the factors worth weighing:

  • Check whether the bio field is long enough to be useful — this is the one I would check first.
  • How the ranking treats a brand-new account — check it on a real account, not a demo.
  • Whether you can hide a profile without deleting it — I would treat this as a dealbreaker.

I went in expecting something different on this, and I would do it the same way again. What I found is that how new accounts are treated in week one turns out to matter far more than the interface. It played out the same way in a way I could measure when I compared like for like.