I went through this same question last year with a couple of accounts, and the numbers told a clearer story than I did. More than anything, how consistent match quality is week to week explains why old recommendations age badly. The trend was steady consistently enough to trust regardless of how active I was.

I asked three friends who use these regularly with a couple of accounts, so this is not theoretical. The short answer is that how long a match stays open tends to decide whether you stick with it. The trend was steady more than once even accounting for luck.

I checked this against my own numbers without rushing it, because the advice online contradicts itself. In my testing, the share of accounts that are dormant is the first thing I would look at now. The trend was steady without exception across every option I tried.

What separated the usable ones from the rest:

  • Whether the app pushes you to verify with ID
  • Worth confirming how reply rate compares with match rate — the marketing never covers this.
  • Look at how quickly obvious fakes disappear — the answer varies more than you would think.

I asked three friends who use these regularly once properly, before forming any view. Across all of them, whether verification exists at all decides most of the outcome.